Primo Pizza

Im about to rate Primo Pizza by Nocatee. Ponte Vedra St Aug. I had a taste last week and it had me questipn who the #1 was here in N. FL. I can smell the New York from here old guy on phone sounds like a guy from howard beach. #yankee #pizza Orderd cheese pie well done. Was there as it came out of oven. Ate it leas than 5 min. 8.5! Cooked perfect, slightly well. Only way to order it. Cheese sauce ingredients here bring me back to nyc. Thank you

- Zach Ahmed -

This is the best pizza I have ever had since I moved to Florida. As a native from Brooklyn and then Staten Islander, this is the pizza that we all love from back home . The proprietors were extremely friendly and reminded me of my roots back in NY. This place is a must if you want NY Pizza .

- Gino La -

If you’re looking for quality real NY pizza, this is your place. This is tasty NY style pizza. The sauce and cheese dough and crust were absolute perfection. One thing I wish pizza places would offer is a spicy pizza. 2 pieces filled me up and my stomach is never ending as I come up on 6 months pregnant. 2 pieces also filled my husband up, too. He was surprised but happy about it since we were able to feed us and our 2 girls plus bring half a pie home. Really quality pizza and a laid back restaurant with space for families. I thought it was funny my husband wore all his Boston hoodie and patriot hat and we walked into an all loving NY sports covered wall. We bought 2 drinks and a 16 inch pepperoni and got out under $25 plus left overs

- Sarah B -

You really need to check them out! Great pizza and great people. I love their chicken parm and pizza. Everything I've ordered has been top knotch. The dough, ingredients, and rolls are definitely high quality! The people are really kind and professional. My order is always done when they say it will be ready for pick up. I'm so glad I go here often. I love this place!

- Max Dickinson -

This was a nice spot. Stopped in for pizza before football game and they did not disappoint. I didnt expect much but they blew us away. The pizza was so good. Service was good and atmosphere was ok. Definitely see them outgrowing this location. There is seating but not a lot which is the only downside I saw. Not a local but I can see this being a nice local spot for teens and sports fans.

- Nikki Larry -

Had an amazing meal at Primo Pizza! My two pizzas and garlic knots were out-of-this-world delicious, and the prices couldn’t be better. The owners were so warm and welcoming, making our dine-in experience truly special. Can’t wait to come back!

- Linda Dohert -

Very clean establishment. The owner took our order. You don’t see that anymore. What a lovely, friendly guy. Subtle NY accent that made you feel like you were actually visiting NY. We had the buffalo chicken pizza….and it was delicious. You must stop by and try anything on the menu.

- Pace2HomeGroup -

Primo Pizza knocked it out of the park! As a mom of a very picky eater, I’m not exaggerating when I say this place is a gem. My son Jake, who usually turns his nose up at just about everything, took one bite and said, “Mom, this is our new Friday night spot.” Enough said! From the moment we walked in, the service was warm, welcoming, and attentive. You can feel the pride they take in every detail. And the food? Pure perfection. Crispy crust, rich sauce, fresh toppings and every bite felt like a love letter from Italy. So grateful to have found a place where the food is fabulous and the vibes are even better. Primo Pizza, you’ve officially earned a spot in our family traditions! See you next Friday!

- Holly Walther -